Reb Arie's Midrash

The Joys of Jewishing

Omar Khadr vs The Queen

leave a comment »

August 19th, 2009 | Tikkun Daily

Criminal conduct in Canada is normally prosecuted by a Crown counsel representing the formal person of the Canadian state, this being The Queen. 

This time the situation is reversed — it is The Queen on trial, and the prosecutor is a remarkably foolish young man named Omar Khadr, who is the last prisoner of a western nation at Gitmo. Omar Khadr was 15 years old when he allegedly threw a grenade and killed a US soldier fighting in Afghanistan.

 Precisely why Omar Khadr is the last western prisoner at Gitmo is a tale that will come to define Canada in the 21st century. Barely 10 years into the century and Canada has used the ship of state to ram the lifeboats of six Canadian citizens. All of them are Arabs.

 I cannot claim that the ship of state was steered politically. The Canadian citizens in question were victmised under both Conservative and Liberal administrations.  

15 year old Omar Khadr

The most visible Arab victim is now the young man named Omar Khadr. Omar comes from a family of proudly fanatical Islamist Muslims. Omar is a victim twice. Canada has victimised him. So has his family of origin.

 Omar has been allowed to languish in the military prison of a nation with a border running 4,000 km from New Brunsiwck to British Columbia. In American terms the border runs 2500 miles from Maine as far west as Washington State. There are few Canadians who do not live within two hours of the International Boundary.

Omar has been victimised by his family, and not due to the warped values the family espouses. Children grow up in such homes all the time and they either get over it as adults or they perpetuate the cycle. Omar’s family victimised him because they permitted a 15 year old to encounter combat.

 Fighting in the field is terrifying for an adult. I simply cannot imagine what it feels like for an adolsescent. I can imagine what it feels like as the parent of an adolescent, the parent in question hating toy guns and banning them (without succ

The 22 year old Omar, still in Gitmo

ess). I can accept the fanaticism of the Khadr family. I cannot accept the child abuse: encouraging a 15 year old to fight is child abuse.

 The response of the Canadian government in this matter is shocking. It is quite consistent with Canadian history, however, for the 20th century response to the admittance of Jews fleeing Hitler before the War began was an elegant phrase that chills me whenever I encounter it.

 None is too many.

 Tomorrow I will profile the six Arabs who have been targeted by the Canadian government.

Written by rebarie

January 9, 2010 at 18:50

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.